|
|
Information on
Lap Belts
First, it should be understood that it is perfectly safe to use
a lap belt to install harnessed child restraints. In the US,
all harnessed child restraints must pass the current standards using a lap
only belt. There is a stricter standard
that allows the use of a tether. However, for
any belted individual, they do not provide adequate protection. They generally prevent the individual from being
ejected, but do not protect the head, neck, spine or internal organs
adequately.
There are two types of injury associated
with using a lap only belt:
- Head and/or neck injury. This is caused when the individual is thrown forward and has no upper body
restraint. They continue moving forward until they are stopped by
something. Many times, it is the head that contacts the interior of the
vehicle - dashboard, front seats, consoles, door
frames, even the floor of the vehicle or the individual's knees. The
injuries can be severe brain trauma from impacting something at a high
rate of speed, cuts, abrasions, skull fractures, broken neck, jaw
fractures, orbital fractures, etc. The neck can also be severely injured
including the spinal cord being severed. The spinal
cord is not able to be stretched beyond a
certain point. In frontal crashes, a lap only belt will hold the lower
body in place, but the heavy head will pull the upper body forward at a
high rate. If the head does not contact anything to stop the rapid forward
motion, the neck will eventually stop the head, but the force of this will
stretch the neck bones, muscles and even the spinal cord - often beyond
it's limit. Children and adults both have been paralyzed or killed in this
manner - their spinal cord simply wasn't capable
of stretching enough to withstand the crash force.
- Seat Belt Syndrome. Seat Belt Syndrome, or SBS, is a phrase that was originally coined by the medical community in
the late 1950s and early 1960s to describe injuries that physicians were
seeing as a result of occupants wearing lap-belt-only restraints in
frontal collisions. These injuries typically include: (1) severe abdominal
injuries, (2) fractures of the lumbar spine, and (3) serious closed head
and facial injuries. These injuries are primarily the result of the
occupant's body jackknifing over the lap belt, at the waist, during the
collision. Under such circumstances, the lap belt causes extreme force to
be applied along the pelvis to the mid-section of the occupant. Securing
the waist without securing the upper torso leads to increased head and
neck velocities, which can cause serious head and neck injuries following
either a head strike or inertial loading of the spine. A majority of these
injuries can be prevented by the installation of an integrated three-point
belt or other upper-torso restraint. (http://www.mobar.net/journal/1999/mayjun/langdon.htm)
Click on image to see the difference between a lap belt only and shoulder belt
When the lap belt does all the restraining, it, and the part of the body
it is holding, take the entire force of the crash. On a child, the lap
belt does not sit down on the hips, as it should, but most often rides up
over the soft abdominal area. In a crash, the lap belt pulls toward the seat back and the body is
pulled away from the seat back. These conflicting forces concentrate a lot
of energy on two things that are very vulnerable - the abdominal organs, and the spine. The injuries that are associated
with SBS include, but are not limited to:
- liver
- kidney
- spleen
- intestinal
- stomach damage.
Some of these organs get damaged beyond repair, meaning life-long handicap or death. The other injury is paralysis
- not from neck injury, but from the lap belt actually severing the lower part of the spinal cord.
Kathleen Weber's research paper "Crash Protection for Child Passengers" says:
The question of fatality reduction effectiveness of rear-seat lap vs.
lap/shoulder belts has recently been addressed in an extensive
double-pair analysis by Morgan in which children of age 5 through 14
were included and evaluated separately. The conclusions for
rear-outboard occupants in this age group are that lap-belted children
were 38% less likely to die than unrestrained children, while lap/
shoulder-belted children were less likely by 52%. The
lap/shoulder belt was found to reduce fatalities 26% over lap belts alone
for children 5 through 14 in all crashes and 31% in frontal crashes, and
children derived more relative benefit from the lap/shoulder belt than did
the adult groups. Further analysis with supplemental cause of death data
indicated that both types of belted children were somewhat more likely to
receive abdominal injuries than unrestrained children, but the increase
for the adult groups in lap belts was much greater. Finally, both belt
systems markedly reduced fatal head injuries, but these were still twice
as likely among lap-belted than lap/shoulder-belted children. This study makes it clear that shoulder belt use is very
beneficial for older children.
With a lap belt, you only have two anchor
points...two points of protection. On most children, those two points are
going to be poorly positioned. A lap/shoulder belt provides three points
of protection, include upper body protection, and a booster that must
be utilized with a lap/shoulder belt properly positions those points for
optimal effectiveness.
Many of the injuries associated with lap only belts are also
associated with shield boosters.
A booster seat should NEVER be used with a lap-only belt.
Children up to 40 lbs are best protected in a harnessed seat - either a convertible seat, a
forward-facing only seat, or a combination seat.
Links
Options for kids over 40 lbs with lap only belts |
Car Seat Specialty Airway
Britax Husky
Ride Ryte Booster with E-Z-On Kid-Y Harness
Fisher Price
Futura 20/60 |
- Car Seat Specialty
Airway retails at $99.99. Harness can be
used from 22-50 lbs. Seat converts to a high back
belt-positioning booster for use from 30-80 lbs.
- Britax
Marathon retails at $249.99.
Britax
Wizard retails at $269.99. Restraint uses internal five-point
harness. In the forward-facing position, it can be used with a
lap only belt up to 65 lbs. Tether included, but not required.
- Britax
Husky retails at $239.99. Restraint uses internal
five-point harness. Can be used with a lap only belt up to 50
lbs. Must be tethered from 50 lbs up. Rated for use from
20 to 80 lbs.
- E-Z-On Harnesses. The
86-Y Harness
can be used from 30-168 lbs. The
Kid-Y Harness can be used from 30-80 lbs in school
buses and from 40-80 lbs in family vehicles. The harness
consists of a shoulder
harness attached to single strap attaches to lap only belt; it must be
tethered at all times. For young children, the
Ride Ryte booster must be
used with the Kid-Y and is recommended when using the 86-Y between
40-80 lbs. Suggested minimum use is 40
lbs. For more information and prices on the harnesses, contact
E-Z-On at 1-800-323-6598. For information on the Ride Ryte
booster, contact Michele Palumbo at 1-866-396-6776
- Fisher Price Futura, discontinued spring 2001, retailed at $95.
Was made in
both a five-point harness model (shown) and tray-shield “four point”
model. Can be used with a lap only belt. Rated for use
from 20-60 lbs. Check online stores or for "new in box" on
eBay.
- Britax Laptop, discontinued September 2002, retailed at $49.99.
Restraint fits over the lap of the child. Can be used with a
lap only belt, as well as lap shoulder. Rated for use from 30
to 65 lbs with lap only belt. Check online stores or for "new
in box" on eBay.
|
Britax Marathon
Britax Wizard
E-Z-On 86-Y Harness
Britax Laptop
|
Retro-fitting shoulder belts: This may be an expensive option, and some vehicle
dealers will not accept the liability of retro-fitting. Many models, including Jeep, GM, Chrysler, and Ford
vehicles do have retrofit kits available for outboard belts. There are no
vehicles that can have a middle seating position retrofit with a shoulder belt.
The parent should check with the dealer as well as the corporate headquarters to
discuss pricing and availability of retro-fit kits and installation.
Ultimately, a vehicle with lap/shoulder belts and head restraints in all
used seating positions needs to be
considered. Except for securing car seats, lap belts do not
provide adequate protection.
If a lap
belt MUST be used until other alternatives are found, it should be worn
low and snug over the hips. An adult is safer in a
lap-only belt than a child. |
HOME 
